
South Seas
Best for families, multi-bedroom villas, private beach access and on‑site water activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
South Seas is a large, 330‑acre Captiva Island resort with private Gulf beach, family programming, villas and on-site marina — read this if you want island, family or multi-bedroom options. Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa is a full-service waterfront Marriott in Fort Myers (Punta Rassa) with a spa, multiple pools and meeting space — read this if you want a branded resort with spa and easy access to Sanibel/Captiva boat departures.
Updated

Best for families, multi-bedroom villas, private beach access and on‑site water activities.

Best for travelers who prefer a full‑service Marriott with a spa, multiple dining outlets and meeting facilities near Sanibel ferry/boat options.
When South Seas wins: choose South Seas if you want an island setting with 2.5 miles of private Gulf‑front beach, multiple pools and family amenities (kids club, waterslides, marina and multi‑bedroom villas).
When Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa wins: pick the Marriott for a standard full‑service hotel experience — easy Marriott brand expectations, an on‑site full‑service spa, several restaurants, extensive meeting space and quick access to Sanibel/Captiva boat trips from the Fort Myers side.
Bottom line: South Seas feels like a private Captiva beach preserve and resort complex geared to families and longer stays in villas; Marriott Sanibel Harbour is a convenient, full‑service waterfront hotel and spa at the Sanibel gateway for meetings, spa stays, and travelers seeking Marriott brand consistency.
| Category | South Seas | Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large island resort and wildlife preserve focused on family activities and a private Gulf beach. | Full‑service, Marriott‑branded waterfront resort with spa and meeting facilities. |
| Location | On Captiva Island with private Gulf frontage; island access involves boat/bridge travel from the mainland. | Fort Myers (Punta Rassa) waterfront, positioned at the Sanibel gateway and close to Sanibel Harbour departures. |
| Size / rooms | Extensive property with many villas, cottages and multi‑bedroom homes (numerous 1–6 bedroom unit types). | 347 guestrooms including studio and tower rooms plus several suite types. |
| Who it's for | Families, groups, beach-focused stays, guests wanting multi‑bedroom units and marina access. | Spa guests, conference/meeting groups, travelers who prefer a full‑service branded hotel near Sanibel. |
| Pools & water | Six outdoor pools, waterslide, family pool complex and a separate adults‑only pool area; private Gulf beach (2.5 miles of shoreline). | Three outdoor pools and 1 indoor pool (listing shows 3 outdoor pools and 1 indoor pool), plus waterfront/sanibel harbour access. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on‑site options (Harborside, Redfish Grill, Beach House, Flippers, Scoops & Slices, Tarpon Bar, Provisions, Starbucks). | Four restaurants, a bar/lounge and a snack/cafe; room service available during limited hours. |
| Spa & wellness | Kay Casperson Spa and Boutique with massages, facials, mani/pedi, sauna/shower area and seven treatment rooms. | Full‑service spa offering massages, body treatments and facials plus fitness classes and 24‑hour-ish fitness facilities. |
| Meetings & events | Multiple indoor/outdoor wedding and event venues (East Lawn, Sunset Pointe, The Studio) and several meeting rooms; largest venues accommodate hundreds. | Conference center with about 9,684 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms; ballroom and banquet spaces for events and corporate meetings. |
| Transport & access | Island property — access requires the on‑site check‑in at plantation address and travel to/off island; resort trolley and golf carts on property. | Mainland hotel near Sanibel Harbour; typical road access and local parking (self/valet fees may apply). |
| Family vs adults | Family‑oriented with Camp‑tiva kids club but also an adults‑only pool area. | All-ages resort (not adults‑only) with family‑friendly amenities. |
South Seas sits on Captiva Island with 2.5 miles of private Gulf beach and an on‑site marina.
Choose South Seas for an island‑front, beach‑first stay and direct marina access.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa sits on the Fort Myers waterfront at Punta Rassa, close to Sanibel Harbour and ferry/boat departures to the islands.
Pick the Marriott when you want mainland road access, easy meeting logistics and quick boat departures to Sanibel/Captiva.
South Seas emphasizes a variety of villas, cottages and multi‑bedroom homes alongside standard rooms.
South Seas is the better choice for families or groups needing multi‑bedroom accommodations and more space.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour has 347 guestrooms in tower and waterfront room configurations plus suites.
Choose the Marriott for predictable, single‑room hotel accommodations and brand consistency.
South Seas offers multiple dining venues across the property, from casual to a steakhouse and beachfront restaurant.
South Seas gives more beachfront, island‑style dining and family casual options across a large property.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour provides four restaurants, a lounge/bar and limited room service hours.
The Marriott is a solid hotel dining option with several on‑site restaurants and convenient room service.
South Seas centers on beach access and a family pool complex plus multiple other pools across the grounds.
South Seas is for guests who prioritize beach time, shelling and a large water‑play complex for families.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour offers multiple outdoor pools and waterfront views alongside marina/harbour access.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour works well for guests who want multiple pool options and easy harbour access without staying on an island.
South Seas operates the Kay Casperson Spa plus fitness and activity programming across the resort.
South Seas mixes a full spa program with family‑friendly resort activities and low‑key evening dining/entertainment.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour has a full‑service spa, fitness facilities and a bar/lounge for evening drinks.
The Marriott is a straightforward choice for guests who want a hotel spa and on‑property fitness options with nearby dining choices.

South Seas — 2.5 miles of private Gulf frontage and easy shelling right off the resort beaches.

Marriott Sanibel Harbour — nearly 9,684 sq ft of conference space and multiple meeting rooms for events.

South Seas — wide range of villas, cottages and multi‑bedroom homes that suit families and groups.

Marriott Sanibel Harbour — full‑service spa, multiple restaurants and a consistent Marriott hotel experience.
South Seas — it’s explicitly family‑oriented with Camp‑tiva kids programming, six pools, waterslides and multi‑bedroom units.
Marriott Sanibel Harbour sits at the Sanibel gateway and is close to Sanibel Harbour departures; South Seas operates its own marina on Captiva for boat tours from the island.
No — neither is presented as all‑inclusive. South Seas charges a mandatory resort fee that includes select in‑room internet, beach access and other items; Marriott may charge extra for breakfast and parking per its policies.
South Seas does not allow pets except ADA service animals; Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa pet policy is not published in the supplied listing.
Explore how South Seas stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·