
South Seas
Best for families and multi-day stays that want on-site activities, multiple pools and private Gulf-front beach access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
South Seas is a large, all-ages Captiva Island resort with private Gulf frontage, multiple pools, a marina and several on-site restaurants — a good read for families or anyone who wants an activity-rich island base. Best Western Plus Beach Resort is a familiar branded beachfront hotel on Fort Myers Beach with kitchen-equipped rooms and complimentary full breakfast — useful for travelers who prefer a straightforward, recognizable beach stay.
Updated

Best for families and multi-day stays that want on-site activities, multiple pools and private Gulf-front beach access.

Best for travelers wanting a familiar, branded beachfront hotel with kitchen-equipped rooms and a complimentary full breakfast.
When South Seas wins: Choose South Seas if you want a resort that functions like a beach destination — private Gulf frontage, six outdoor pools, a marina and a long list of on-site activities and restaurants for families and groups.
When Best Western Plus Beach Resort wins: Choose Best Western Plus Beach Resort if you want an easier, branded beachfront stay on Fort Myers Beach with kitchenettes in many rooms, included full breakfast, and straightforward amenities.
Bottom line: South Seas is the destination resort (bigger, more amenities, island setting). Best Western Plus Beach Resort is a simpler, reliable beachfront hotel option for guests who prefer a branded product and complimentary breakfast.
| Category | South Seas | Best Western Plus Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large island resort and activity base across 330 acres; resort trolley, marina and family programming. | Well-known midscale brand hotel on Fort Myers Beach with a straightforward beachfront hotel experience. |
| Location | Private Gulf-front on Captiva Island (island property reached by boat/ferry; no road access to the resort interior). | Beachfront on Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach (mainland; on-site beach access). |
| Size | 330-acre resort with many villages, villas, cottages and multi-bedroom units (26 room/unit types listed). | 74 air-conditioned rooms across a single branded beachfront hotel. |
| Who it's for | Families, groups, couples wanting resort amenities and on-site activities. | Travelers wanting a familiar branded hotel and simple beach access with included breakfast. |
| Pools | Six outdoor pools, waterslide and separate adults-only pool area (The Cove). | One outdoor pool listed; pool hours and features limited vs a large resort. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Harborside, Redfish Grill, Beach House, Flippers, Tarpon Bar, Scoops & Slices, Provisions, Starbucks). | Not published: signature on-site restaurant names are not listed in supplier listing; complimentary full breakfast is standard. |
| Spa & wellness | Kay Casperson Spa and Boutique on property with multiple treatment rooms and sauna area. | Health or beauty spa listed as 'nearby' rather than a named on-site spa in the supplier listing. |
| Known for | Private 2.5 miles of Gulf-front shell-laden beach, marina, boat tours and island activities. | Branded beachfront location on Fort Myers Beach with kitchen-equipped rooms and free full breakfast. |
| Accessibility / practicalities | Mandatory resort fee applies; check-in minimum age 21; shuttle/boat access considerations for off-island travel. | Free self-parking, free full breakfast, 24-hour front desk; minimum check-in age not published in supplier listing. |
South Seas sits on Captiva Island with private Gulf frontage and a marina; the property is car-free in places and offers a resort trolley.
South Seas is an island resort where getting around the property and enjoying water activities are part of the appeal.
Best Western Plus Beach Resort sits on Estero Boulevard in Fort Myers Beach with direct beach frontage and mainland road access.
Best Western Plus is a straightforward beachfront hotel on the Fort Myers Beach strip with easy road access and local services nearby.
South Seas lists 26 unit types ranging from 1-bedroom villas to 6-bedroom homes and cottages suitable for families and groups.
South Seas offers large, flexible accommodation options designed for families and groups rather than a single standard hotel room.
Best Western Plus Beach Resort offers standard hotel rooms and suites; many listings include kitchen facilities and private balconies with Gulf views.
Best Western Plus gives travelers hotel-style rooms with a high proportion of kitchen-equipped options and consistent branded room types.
South Seas runs multiple on-site restaurants and casual outlets covering seafood, steakhouse, pizza, coffee and poolside drinks.
South Seas offers a range of on-site dining suited to families and resort guests, including both casual and refined options.
Best Western Plus Beach Resort's supplier listing emphasizes a complimentary full breakfast and convenience features; on-site full-service restaurants are not named in the listing.
Best Western Plus focuses on a dependable breakfast offering and in-room kitchens for convenience rather than a wide restaurant roster.
South Seas offers six outdoor pools, a waterslide and a separate adults-only pool area, plus private Gulf beach access.
South Seas is built around multiple pool experiences and a long stretch of private beach for guests.
Best Western Plus Beach Resort has a single outdoor pool listed and direct access to Fort Myers Beach.
Best Western Plus provides a standard hotel pool plus direct beachfront access; the scale is smaller than a destination resort.
South Seas includes a namesake spa and a fitness center, plus poolside and beachfront bars for relaxed evening options.
South Seas supports wellness with a full spa and has several relaxed nighttime dining/drink outlets on property.
Best Western Plus Beach Resort lists basic wellness services and nearby spa options rather than a named on-site spa.
Best Western Plus handles basic wellness and evening needs through hotel conveniences and nearby businesses rather than a full spa/nightlife program.

South Seas — kids' club (Camp-tiva), family pools, waterslide and many kid-friendly dining options.

Best Western Plus Beach Resort — consistent Best Western product, kitchen-equipped rooms and free full breakfast.

South Seas — multiple on-site restaurants and poolside bars covering casual to refined meals.

Best Western Plus Beach Resort — complimentary full breakfast and kitchen facilities in many rooms reduce dining costs.
South Seas — it has Camp-tiva, multiple family pools, waterslide and family-friendly dining; it's positioned as a family resort.
South Seas — the resort lists multiple named restaurants and casual outlets. Best Western Plus's supplier listing does not publish a roster of on-site restaurants but does include complimentary breakfast.
No. The supplier listing and provided facts show Best Western Plus Beach Resort is not adults-only.
No — neither property is an all-inclusive. Best Western Plus includes a complimentary full breakfast; South Seas charges a mandatory resort fee but room rates do not include all meals.
Explore how South Seas stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·